Preference Lawsuits: When Can Vendors Be Forced to Return Payments?
Few things surprise a vendor more than being sued to return money it was paid months earlier. Yet, a trustee or Chapter 11 debtor-in-possession can recover certain payments made to vendors before a bankruptcy filing, known as preferences. Recoveries in a preference lawsuit can help fund the estate and improve distributions to unsecured creditors.
Bankruptcy Code Section 547 defines a preference as a transfer of the debtor’s property to a creditor, on account of an existing debt, made while the debtor was insolvent, that leaves the creditor better off than it would have been in a Chapter 7. A debtor is presumed insolvent during the 90 days before filing Chapter 11. For insiders, such as officers, directors and affiliates, the look-back period is one year.
Commonly challenged transfers include catch-up payments on past-due invoices, lump-sum payments after a vendor threatens to cut off supply, payments under new or tightened credit terms and repayments of insider loans. Liens granted to secure existing debt can also be avoided. A lawsuit to recover such payments is informally known as “clawback” litigation.
A debtor that understands its potential preference claims gains leverage. Mapping payments made within the look-back periods helps estimate the value of avoidance actions, which can fund a plan or be assigned to a creditor trust. It also strengthens negotiations: critical vendors may agree to continue supplying on favorable terms in exchange for a waiver of preference claims. Planning also helps a company avoid insider payments that would invite later litigation and scrutiny.
However, vendors can raise certain defenses to preference claims, such as the following:
- The ordinary-course-of-business defense — This protects payments made during the parties’ usual dealings or according to ordinary business terms in the industry. Courts compare payment timing, amounts and methods during the preference period with the parties’ historical pattern. Unusual collection pressure undermines the defense.
- The new-value defense — This credits a vendor for goods or services it supplied after receiving a preferential payment, thereby reducing its exposure. A related defense covers contemporaneous exchanges for new value, such as cash-on-delivery sales.
Since 2019, bankruptcy trustees must exercise reasonable due diligence and consider a defendant’s known defenses before suing.
Preference litigation often turns on detailed payment histories and industry practice. An experienced Chapter 11 counsel can analyze transaction data, evaluate defenses early and decide which claims are worth pursuing or settling. For debtors, that means maximizing estate value without alienating essential suppliers. For vendors, it means building a credible defense and negotiating a fair resolution.
The Law Offices of Michael Jay Berger in Beverly Hills represents businesses throughout California in all aspects of Chapter 11 bankruptcy, including preference litigation and pre-bankruptcy planning. Call 310-271-6223 or contact us online to schedule a free initial consultation.
